We have a winner!

You lovelies have too sharp of an eye for my silly games...

Yes, the first shoe is the delicious Camden Leather Brogues from Jcrew for $250.

The second pair I found/bought/love is from *Forever21 for a whopping $24.80

*Forever has recently changed the look of this shoe to a more "vintage style" oxford flat... which is somewhat unfortunate in my book.

(the only time you'll ever hear me remark about something vintage being "unfortunate")